Hello,
As Banned Book Week winds down I wanted to share with you some of my thoughts. Librarians love to share their mutual disgust for book challenges. It is a painful process to reevaluate whether a book should be in the collection or not based on a complaint of one individual. (Most) Librarians love books and feel that information should be freely accessible to all.
But then their are other people who feel that their only action is to self-censor their library. This willful hiding/destruction/theft of materials is the bane of a librarians existence. Ever tried to find a book and it's not there? It is dreadfully annoying and means disappointing a patron. These actions also indicates a stubborn arrogance on the side of the self-censor(s). They believe that they know what is best for everybody. Their opinion matters more than anybody else so they are going to save the community. This savior complex is prideful hubris. How dare anyone tell me what I should be able to read? I can make my own choices, thank you very much.
However before I trot off on my librarian high horse I want to share this story with you all. Starting in the fall of 2008 two library workers took upon themselves to self-censor Alan Moore's graphic novel The League of Extraordinary Gentleman: The Black Dossier. The entire wonderful story is contained here. To me this story illustrates a fine point: Even those who proclaim to love books will take it upon themselves to circumvent the system. For these women it was a crime of opportunity, rather than desperation. Nobody is immune to the virus of censorship.
If you are a parent then monitor what your kids are reading. Talk to them about books that you are unsure of. Heck even read the books with them and then talk about it.
If you are a kid and you read a book that disturbs you, then talk to your parents about it. Or your teacher. Or your friends. Perhaps that book wasn't appropriate for your age level.
If you are a librarian then spend every moment possible building up your reader's advisory. Develop a list of "clean" books. Develop a list of books for multiple age levels. Be proactive.
If you are a librarian administrator then develop a transparent book challenge process. And keep up with other book challenges across the country. Communicate any concerns you may have with your selectors about placement.
Above All: Do Not Be Give In To Those Few Book Banners Who Would Make Choices For All Of Us.
Showing posts with label reccomendations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reccomendations. Show all posts
2010-10-04
2008-04-25
Better late than Never
Hey, apologies for the lateness of this post. Sometimes the words aren't a-flowing as much as they should. So today's topic: Graphic Novels and Libraries.
In the library where I work I have come to love our graphic novel section. It has a wide variety of titles, several different genres, and is currently the second highest circulating items (behind AV materials, like DVDs, CDs, etc.). When I was first employed, I admit that my knowledge was somewhat limited. Due to this inexperience I dedicated myself to reading at least 10-12 a year. As I dug in further that number tripled. I also decided to look into the benefits of graphic novels when it comes to those who have reading difficulties. Kids with limited reading skills benefit from the combination of art and words. This helps with comprehension. Also the fact that these books are usually 100-150 pages long. As the reader is able to get through a series there confidence grows and they decide to raise the stakes quicker.
Let's also not forget that these stories are fun. Yeah I said it. The links to sci-fi and fantasy are obvious, however there is also an escapism. Entire new worlds are developed and histories created. Kids and adults can easily lose themselves in these stories. On the other hand, recent graphic novels have expanded their storytelling to the autobiographical. Modern classics along these lines include Persepolis, American Splendor, and Blankets. So readers get the best of all worlds.
I also decided to work on my fellow librarians to give graphic novels a shot. There was some resistance. At least one librarian told me "I will never read those (graphic novels) I don't have time." I'm still working on that one. However I was ecstatic this week when an older librarian told me she was going to try her first graphic novel: Persepolis. I had given this same book to my mom for Christmas as her first graphic novel and it was a success. So I now consider Persepolis a great gateway reccomendation.
Anyway I've assembled an "If you like..." list here for anyone's whose interested:
If you like mysteries such as those written by Sue Grafton or the "V.I. Warshawski" series try Whiteout written by Greg Rucka.
If you like apocalyptic tales like I am Legend or The Road try The Walking Dead written by Robert Kirkman.
If you are looking for books for the tween girl inside try Spiderman Loves Mary Jane written by Sean McKeever.
If you like autobiograhical romance try Blankets by Craig Thompson.
If you like true crime try From Hell by Alan Moore.
If you like adventure and classic british literature try The League of Extraordinary Gentleman written by Alan Moore.
(Okay well basically anything by Alan Moore)
If you like crazy cosmic anarchy try The Invisibles written by Grant Morrison.
If you like political thrillers try Ex Machina by Brian K. Vaughan.
If you like fables with a modern twist try Fables written by Bill Willingham.
If you like Children of Men try Y the Last Man by Brian K. Vaughan.
As you can see there really is something for everyone. It's not just super-hero stuff. Have a great weekend! Book Slave.
In the library where I work I have come to love our graphic novel section. It has a wide variety of titles, several different genres, and is currently the second highest circulating items (behind AV materials, like DVDs, CDs, etc.). When I was first employed, I admit that my knowledge was somewhat limited. Due to this inexperience I dedicated myself to reading at least 10-12 a year. As I dug in further that number tripled. I also decided to look into the benefits of graphic novels when it comes to those who have reading difficulties. Kids with limited reading skills benefit from the combination of art and words. This helps with comprehension. Also the fact that these books are usually 100-150 pages long. As the reader is able to get through a series there confidence grows and they decide to raise the stakes quicker.
Let's also not forget that these stories are fun. Yeah I said it. The links to sci-fi and fantasy are obvious, however there is also an escapism. Entire new worlds are developed and histories created. Kids and adults can easily lose themselves in these stories. On the other hand, recent graphic novels have expanded their storytelling to the autobiographical. Modern classics along these lines include Persepolis, American Splendor, and Blankets. So readers get the best of all worlds.
I also decided to work on my fellow librarians to give graphic novels a shot. There was some resistance. At least one librarian told me "I will never read those (graphic novels) I don't have time." I'm still working on that one. However I was ecstatic this week when an older librarian told me she was going to try her first graphic novel: Persepolis. I had given this same book to my mom for Christmas as her first graphic novel and it was a success. So I now consider Persepolis a great gateway reccomendation.
Anyway I've assembled an "If you like..." list here for anyone's whose interested:
If you like mysteries such as those written by Sue Grafton or the "V.I. Warshawski" series try Whiteout written by Greg Rucka.
If you like apocalyptic tales like I am Legend or The Road try The Walking Dead written by Robert Kirkman.
If you are looking for books for the tween girl inside try Spiderman Loves Mary Jane written by Sean McKeever.
If you like autobiograhical romance try Blankets by Craig Thompson.
If you like true crime try From Hell by Alan Moore.
If you like adventure and classic british literature try The League of Extraordinary Gentleman written by Alan Moore.
(Okay well basically anything by Alan Moore)
If you like crazy cosmic anarchy try The Invisibles written by Grant Morrison.
If you like political thrillers try Ex Machina by Brian K. Vaughan.
If you like fables with a modern twist try Fables written by Bill Willingham.
If you like Children of Men try Y the Last Man by Brian K. Vaughan.
As you can see there really is something for everyone. It's not just super-hero stuff. Have a great weekend! Book Slave.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)